Chairperson
Home

The enabling layer

Instruments for the annual cycle of a well-run board.

Beneath education, peers and coaching sits a practical framework — the Governance Evaluation and Accountability Toolkit — for evaluating the board and the chief executive.

Part one

Board evaluation: seven statements, two prompts.

Directors rate each statement. Two open questions follow.

Strategy

2 STATEMENTS
  • The board spends most of its time on strategy rather than operational detail.
  • The board and management share a clear view of the organisation's long-term direction.

Culture

2 STATEMENTS
  • Directors feel able to dissent without consequence.
  • Discussion is robust, respectful and reaches resolution.

Information

1 STATEMENT
  • Board papers arrive in time and give what is needed to decide.

Chair and committees

2 STATEMENTS
  • The chair runs meetings that are focused, inclusive and decisive.
  • Committees have clear mandates and report usefully to the board.
OPEN PROMPT 1

What is the single biggest improvement this board could make?

OPEN PROMPT 2

What risks is the board not discussing enough?

Statements are illustrative of the framework's areas.

Part two

The CEO scorecard: four weighted quadrants.

Weights reflect where a chief executive's contribution matters most to the board.

Strategic

40%

Sample KPIs

  • Progress against agreed strategic milestones
  • Market position and growth initiatives
  • Quality of strategic options brought to the board

Qualitative prompt

How well has the CEO translated strategy into executable priorities?

Financial and operational

25%

Sample KPIs

  • Revenue, margin or surplus against plan
  • Cash and capital discipline
  • Operational resilience and risk management

Qualitative prompt

Where has execution surprised the board, positively or otherwise?

Culture and talent

20%

Sample KPIs

  • Leadership bench and succession readiness
  • Engagement and retention of key people
  • Alignment of behaviour with stated values

Qualitative prompt

What is it like to work for this CEO?

Board partnership

15%

Sample KPIs

  • Candour and timeliness of information
  • Quality of the Chair–CEO relationship
  • Responsiveness to board challenge

Qualitative prompt

Does the board hear bad news early?

The annual cycle

When each instrument is used.

  • Q3

    Board evaluation

    Directors complete the evaluation; the chair reviews themes and agrees actions.

    Working draft
  • Q4

    CEO targets

    The chair and CEO agree next year's scorecard targets against the four quadrants.

    Working draft
  • Annual

    Redacted peer benchmarking

    A qualitative comparison with redacted peer examples. These are not statistical norms.

    Planned

Bring rigour to the board's own year.

Toolkit editors are included with Fellow and Principal membership. Enterprise engagements can scope a custom internal review.